Robert's Rules of Order for Nonprofit Boards: What You Actually Need

Robert's Rules of Order is 700 pages long. It was written in 1876 for large deliberative assemblies and has been revised eleven times since. Almost none of it applies to a seven-person nonprofit board meeting held monthly over Zoom.

And yet, many nonprofits cite Robert's Rules in their bylaws as the governing authority for board meetings — and then have no idea what that actually means in practice.

This guide covers the handful of procedures that actually matter for small nonprofit boards: how to make and handle motions, how voting works, what quorum means, and how to handle the situations that come up most often.

Why parliamentary procedure exists

The purpose of parliamentary procedure isn't formality for its own sake. It exists to ensure that decisions are made deliberately, that everyone has a chance to participate, and that the outcome is unambiguous.

For a nonprofit board, the most important thing parliamentary procedure does is create a clear record. When a motion is properly made, seconded, discussed, and voted on, the minutes can document exactly what was decided and by what authority. That record protects the organization and the individual board members.

The basic vocabulary

Motion — A formal proposal for the board to take an action or make a decision. "I move that we approve the 2026 budget as presented."

Second — A signal from another board member that the motion deserves to be discussed. Seconding doesn't mean you support the motion — just that you think it should be considered.

Debate/Discussion — The board's opportunity to discuss the motion before voting. The chair manages this to ensure all members can participate.

Vote — The board's decision on the motion. Most motions pass by simple majority of members present.

Table/Postpone — Setting the motion aside temporarily. "I move to table this until we have the financial projections."

Call the question — Ending debate and moving to a vote immediately. Requires a two-thirds majority to pass in standard practice.

Point of order — Interrupting to note that procedure is not being followed. "Point of order — we haven't established quorum."

How a motion works in practice

Here's the full sequence for a typical board action:

1. Member makes the motion: "I move that we approve the executive director's performance review and authorize a 4% salary increase effective July 1."

2. Another member seconds it: "Second."

3. Chair opens discussion: "The motion is on the floor. Discussion?"

4. Board discusses. The chair facilitates, ensures everyone who wants to speak can.

5. Chair calls the vote: "All in favor?" [Members indicate yes.] "Opposed?" [Members indicate no.] "Abstentions?"

6. Chair announces the result: "The motion carries, 6 in favor, 1 opposed."

7. Secretary records it in the minutes with the exact motion text and vote count.

That's it. Most board actions follow this sequence, and it takes less than two minutes when the board is prepared.

Types of votes and when they apply

Simple majority (more than half of those voting) — The default for most motions. Budget approvals, policy adoptions, committee appointments.

Two-thirds majority — Required by Robert's Rules (and often by bylaws) for certain significant actions: ending debate, suspending rules, removing an officer, or amending bylaws.

Unanimous consent — For routine or uncontested items, the chair can say "Is there any objection to approving the consent agenda?" If no one objects, it passes without a formal vote.

Roll call vote — Each member states their vote aloud and it's recorded by name. Used for significant decisions where individual positions should be on the record, or when bylaws require it.

Check your bylaws — they may specify vote thresholds for specific actions that override Robert's Rules defaults.

Quorum: the prerequisite for any action

Quorum is the minimum number of board members who must be present for the board to conduct official business. If you don't have quorum, you can't vote on anything.

Most bylaws set quorum at a majority of current board members. If you have nine board members, five need to be present to have quorum. If three seats are vacant, quorum is based on the current membership, not the maximum size — so four of six would be required.

If a meeting starts with quorum but members leave during the meeting, you may lose quorum. The remaining members can't continue conducting official business.

When quorum can't be reached, the board can:

• Discuss items informally (no binding votes)
• Reschedule the meeting
• Take a poll of members outside the meeting (depending on your bylaws and state law)

Email votes and poll votes are a gray area — some state laws allow them, some don't. Your bylaws should address whether action can be taken outside of a meeting.

Handling amendments to motions

Motions can be amended before the vote. The process:

1. Member proposes an amendment: "I'd like to amend the motion to change the effective date from July 1 to October 1."
2. Amendment needs a second.
3. The board discusses and votes on the amendment first.
4. If the amendment passes, the main motion is now in its amended form.
5. The board then votes on the main motion as amended.

Amendments must be germane — related to the subject of the original motion. You can't amend a motion about the budget by adding language about personnel.

Consent agenda: the time-saver for routine items

A consent agenda bundles routine, uncontested items — last meeting's minutes, committee reports, routine renewals — into a single approval. Members review the materials in advance. At the meeting, the chair asks if anyone wants to pull an item for separate discussion. Everything remaining passes with one vote.

Consent agendas can cut 20–30 minutes off a typical board meeting. They also signal respect for board members' time: not everything needs group deliberation.

Reconsideration: revisiting a decision

If the board votes on something and a member wants to revisit the decision, they can move to reconsider. There are rules around this: typically only a member who voted on the prevailing side can make the motion, and it must be done at the same meeting or the next.

Reconsideration exists to correct mistakes or address new information — not to relitigate a decision because you didn't like the outcome. Boards that frequently reconsider decisions are boards that aren't preparing adequately before meetings.

Practical simplifications for small boards

Robert's Rules was designed for assemblies of hundreds. A seven-person board doesn't need all of it. Common simplifications:

Require motions and seconds but allow informal discussion — Don't raise and address speakers like a formal assembly. Just have a conversation, then formalize the decision with a motion and vote.

Skip formal debate rules — For small boards, the chair can simply open discussion and manage it informally without strict speaking-time rules.

Allow members to make and second the same person's motion on common sense items — Some boards relax the second requirement for unanimous consent items.

Document decisions clearly even with relaxed procedure — However informally you run the meeting, the minutes should still capture every motion with exact text and vote count.

What your bylaws should say about parliamentary procedure

Most nonprofit bylaws include a clause like: "The rules contained in the current edition of Robert's Rules of Order shall govern this organization in all cases to which they are applicable and in which they are not inconsistent with these bylaws."

That's standard and fine — but it means you need to know which rules apply when. The most important safeguard is that your bylaws address the situations that come up most often: quorum requirements, vote thresholds for major decisions, officer removal, and bylaw amendments.

When Robert's Rules conflicts with your bylaws, your bylaws govern.

---

Board Manager helps nonprofit boards track meetings, record attendance, and maintain governance records without the paperwork. Start for free.